Skip to content
The competition·Chapter 2.7

How the missions evolved

The 2027 competition is the visible end of five separate task lineages, four of them older than the autonomy mission. Read as task designs rather than as rules, the history explains why each 2027 mission looks the way it does: what the rover has to do, on which objects, measured against which tolerance, and what was deliberately taken out. Two facts surprise most first-time readers. Autonomy became a scored mission only in 2017, and the drone arrived in 2022 as an explicitly unscored trial.

2017Autonomy’s first scored yearNine seasons before 20272017S-URC17-RULES
2022The drone’s first appearanceAn unscored demonstration2022S-URC22-RULES
100 mEquipment servicing approachDown from 0.25 km in 20252026–2027S-URC27-RULES
2Life detections requiredUp from one method in 2023–20262027S-URC27-RULES

Key takeaways

  • Autonomy is the youngest mission and the most changed one. It began in 2017 as a waypoint traverse, became object recognition by 2026, and in 2027 becomes human assistance plus terrain route finding with a 1 m tolerance.
  • Science has tightened into a payload specification. The 2023 mission accepted any one method and a 1–10 g surface sample; 2027 requires two life detections, one of them a bioassay, from at least 10 cm depth.
  • Equipment servicing lost a fifth of its drive and gained dexterity. The approach fell from 0.5 km to 100 m while the manipulation set grew, and the recurring core is torque plus insertion at 1.5 m with a small visual marker.
  • The drone became a field asset. It entered as a consultation, was briefly allowed to replace the rover, and is now a pad-launched Delivery and Autonomy assistant with no wind waiver.

The five mission families

Family First appears Name in 2027 Lineage
Science 2007, as the Scientific Task Astrobiology Mission Scientific Task 2007, Geology and Soil Characterization 2008, Site Survey and Sample Return 2011–2012, Sample Return 2013–2015, Science Cache 2016–2018, Science 2019–2026, Astrobiology 2027
Delivery 2008, as Emergency Navigation Delivery Mission Emergency Navigation 2008, Astronaut Assistance 2011–2016, Extreme Retrieval and Delivery 2017–2022, Extreme Delivery 2023, Delivery 2024–2027
Equipment servicing 2008, as Construction Equipment Servicing Mission Construction 2008, Equipment Servicing Task 2011–2016, Equipment Servicing Mission 2017–2027
Autonomy 2017 Autonomy Mission Autonomous Traversal 2017–2019, Autonomous Navigation 2020–2026, Autonomy in two sub-missions 2027
Aerial 2022, as an unscored demo A regulated equipment class Demo 2022, rover substitute 2023, Delivery assistant 2024–2026, Delivery and Autonomy assistant 2027
The BYU rover at the Mars Desert Research Station in 2009
The 2009 BYU rover on the same site: six wheels, a small arm, an instrument deck and a mast. Two decades of rule changes have not changed the shape of the machine, which is why a chassis and a thermal margin designed to the stable core still transfer to 2027.Peter Hyatt, 2009. CC BY 3.0. Original source Full resolution

Science: the measuring stick

Years Roving time Life detection minimum Sample Cache Stratigraphic profile
2007 1–3 h Investigate geology and palaeontology; digging allowed, no explosives, on-site analysis only Not specified None No
2008 30–60 min plus equal preparation Two separate events, one using visible and infrared spectral analysis Soil and subsurface probes None No
2011–2012 30–60 min Site Survey and Sample Return as separate tasks Not specified None No
2016–2018 Not stated A science cache with a judged hand-off Sample in a cache Container opened by judges No
2023 20–35 min One method or assay of the team’s choosing, onboard 1–10 g, surface, no depth rule Closed container No
2024–2026 20–30 min One capability plus a second capability of the team’s choosing At least 10 cm deep, at least 5 g Sealed, spill-proof when inverted, removable in 5 min Required
2027 20–30 min Two life detections, at least one a bioassay At least 10 cm deep, at least 5 g, unchanged Sealed, unchanged Removed

Three breaks matter more than the trend line. In 2008 science was two scored events with two different instrument classes, so the year rewarded breadth in a way no later year did. In 2013 the survey event disappeared and science became one task. In 2024 the mission gained the 10 cm depth rule, the 5 g floor, the sealed cache, the two-site comparison and the stratigraphic profile all at once, and only the profile came out in 2027 S-URC08-RULES S-URC13-RULES S-URC24-RULES S-URC27-RULES §1.b §1.b.

The design consequence is blunt. An auger producing 1–10 g of surface material satisfied 2023 and fails every rulebook since. Sub-surface acquisition to at least 10 cm with a documented depth has been mandatory for four consecutive seasons, and 2027 adds the bioassay on top of it S-URC24-RULES S-URC27-RULES §1.b.vi §1.b.v.

Delivery: from a speed race to a staged mission

The family starts as Emergency Navigation in 2008: deliver a supply container to a simulated astronaut as fast as possible, with the container capped at 30 × 30 × 15 cm and 6 kg, orientation-independent, and covered in hook-and-loop so the rover had to strap it on rather than grip it. Delivery was within 1 m of the suit, the astronaut was up to 1.5 km away, and line of sight was guaranteed for only 80 % of the course S-URC08-RULES. From 2011 the task became Astronaut Assistance, then a staged retrieval and delivery mission in 2017, and Delivery from 2024.

By 2027 the menu is a set of capabilities rather than a course: open boxes with hinged lids, pick up and deliver objects, read signs carried by astronauts or placed in the field, find equipment in a large search area, and find objects where radio reception is poor. The 2027 rewrite removed one item, the precise marked-path drive, and emphasised that objects appear in a variety of sizes, shapes and weights S-URC26-RULES S-URC27-RULES §1.c.iii §1.c.iii.

Object envelope Value Years in force
Mass Up to 5 kg 2026–2027, with 6 kg for the 2008 container
Bounding size Under 40 × 40 × 40 cm 2018 onward, unchanged
Grasp feature 7.5 cm diameter 2026–2027, widened from 5 cm
Object identity Disclosed at the delivery location, not before 2026–2027
Aerial help Drone allowed, no mobile deployable 2026–2027

The 7.5 cm grasp feature is the sharpest mechanical constraint in the competition. Rocks with natural features are legal targets, so the end effector cannot be designed around a known handle. A 5 kg object with an unknown centre of gravity and a 40 cm envelope is the design case, not an object with a moulded grip.

A rover crossing the rock garden at the Mars Desert Research Station
The Delivery terrain description has not changed since 2008: soft sand, gravel, rough stony ground, boulder fields, vertical drops and steep loose slopes. What changed is that later Delivery tasks are now deliberately out of radio line of sight.Mars Society, 2017. CC BY-SA 4.0. Original source Full resolution

Equipment servicing: the drive collapsed, the dexterity grew

The mission began in 2008 as a construction task: secure half-inch hex bolts on a mock panel between 15 cm and 75 cm above the ground, at up to 45° of inclination, on a drive of up to 0.5 km. In 2011 it became a read-the-instructions task with a printed sequence and 3-prong plugs S-URC08-RULES S-URC11-RULES §3.e.

Years Approach distance
2011–2016 0.5 km
2017–2025 0.25 km
2026–2027 100 m

A fivefold reduction in the drive over sixteen years, with the manipulation content increasing. That is the clearest statement in the rulebook that this mission is an arm mission, not a mobility mission.

Task Years present What it demands
Push buttons, flip switches, turn knobs 2011–2027 Force and travel against an unpublished value
Read a printed sequence on the panel 2011 Text legibility on a vertical surface
Connect a three-prong plug 2011 Insertion with orientation
Sample tube into cache, close lid, turn lock 2026–2027 Insertion plus torque in one sequence
Carry the cache, open the drawer, insert and close 2019–2027 Grasp, alignment and a tight fit
Tighten a captive screw 2019, 2022 Torque with an Allen key
Autonomous typing on a vertical keyboard 2019–2027 Precision with a 2 cm fiducial at the corners
Insert a USB connector 2022, 2026 Fine connector alignment
Turn a quarter-turn lever valve 2026–2027 Torque through 90°
Push a 1.5 in cam-lock hose onto a fitting 2026–2027 Push force, travel and retention
Remove a key, insert it into a second lock, turn it 2027 Grasp, keyway alignment and torque on a 1 cm tag

The churn is constant and the handedness is stable. Every year since 2019 has had at least one torque task and at least one insertion task, and the recurring core is reach at 1.5 m to the ground, grasp of a 5–10 cm feature, torque application, and a small visual marker for feedback S-URC19-RULES S-URC27-RULES §3.d §1.d.ii. A first build can treat that core as the durable requirement and the object list as the annual variable.

The 2027 geometry also reverses the back-to-back order: 2026 ran servicing into autonomous navigation, while 2027 runs Autonomy into Equipment Servicing, possibly only ten minutes apart, from the same command post on an adjacent course S-URC26-RULES S-URC27-RULES §1.a.iv §1.a.iv. That makes the payload and sensor configuration part of the schedule, not only part of the design.

Autonomy: from waypoints to a walking astronaut

Before 2017 no mission required autonomy. The rulebooks said the rover was not required to be autonomous, and the 2017 rules still confined the requirement to one task. It then went from optional to a fifth of the score in a single season S-URC07-RULES-L2 S-URC16-RULES S-URC17-RULES §2.c.

Period Shape Tolerance Abort cost Human role
2017 Reach an object and waypoint set, partial credit within 5 m 5 m for partial credit Not stated None
2019–2022 Staged legs between physical markers: tennis balls, then gates, then AR tags Marker coordinates approximate, search required Not stated None
2026 Two coordinate points, two tagged posts and three objects to highlight on the display 3 m and 2 m Autonomous return free, teleoperation 20 % None
2027 Astronaut assistance worth 50 and route finding worth 50 1 m at targets, 3 m at the astronaut 20 % on a stop or return, 50 % for teleoperation, capped at 50 % A suited astronaut who walks, waits, receives and hands over

The 2027 Follow! task is the one place where the method itself is scored, and the spread is large enough to be a design decision rather than a preference S-URC27-RULES §1.e.vi.

Follow! method Points Share of the 15 available
Astronaut-carried device 5 One third
Visual sign 5 One third
Spoken word or phrase 10 Two thirds
Beckoning gesture 15 Full

The gesture path is worth three times the device path, and it is a perception problem rather than a radio problem. Everything else in the sub-mission is binary, which is why a reliable simple method for Stay!, Fetch!, Come! and Give! is enough.

The drone: five years from demo to field asset

Year Role Launch and mass
2022 Optional demonstration, not scored, with an open invitation for feedback on making it a mission 5 kg cap, 250 g registration threshold, dummy mass guidance
2023 Allowed to fly instead of the rover in Autonomous Navigation 5 kg, dummy mass separate; required dummy mass waived above 24 km/h
2024 Delivery assistant only Drone plus payloads plus dummy mass at 5 kg; waiver above 24 km/h
2025 Delivery assistant 5 kg including dummy mass; waiver above 24 km/h
2026 Delivery assistant Launch from the rover or a start location near the command post; waiver above 24 km/h
2027 Delivery and Autonomy assistant Designated landing pad only; never waived; over 5 kg not permitted to fly

The permanent constraints arrived with the demonstration and never left: rotary wing only and able to hover, no lighter-than-air vehicle, no fixed wing, FAA Remote ID, a TRUST certificate carried by every pilot, below 120 m above ground in Class G airspace, not in the national park, give way to manned aircraft near Hanksville, and a spotter with continuous visual line of sight S-URC22-RULES S-URC27-RULES §4 §2.b. The 2027 change is not a new capability but a narrowing: the airframe is a field asset with a pad, a pilot in the command post and a spotter on the ground.

The review never got easier

Years Review element Scored Cut
2007–2014 None; a video presentation from 2011 Presentation only None
2015–2016 Critical Design Review No, a down-selection gate Pass or fail
2017 Critical Design Review Yes, 100 of 500 Pass or fail
2018 Preliminary Design Review added, CDR becomes the System Acceptance Review Yes, 100 of 500 Pass or fail
2019–2027 PDR and SAR Yes, 100 of 500 Top 36

The review has been a fifth mission since 2017: 100 points and a gate on the other 400. For a first-time team it is the highest-leverage document of the season, and it rewards collected test evidence rather than prose.

Three readings for a first build

  1. The physical problem is twenty years old. 50 kg, off-grid, about 100 °F, no direct view and a real-time link have survived every rulebook read. Time spent on a robust chassis, a thermal margin and a reliable link is never wasted S-URC07-RULES-L1 S-URC27-RULES §2.a.
  2. The score has migrated from manipulation and driving to perception and science. The servicing drive fell fivefold, autonomy went from nothing to 100 points and now includes human interaction, and the science payload went from any instrument to two life detections with a bioassay S-URC11-RULES S-URC27-RULES §1.b.v.
  3. Treat every sub-task as temporary. The 2008 spectral analysis, the 2011–2012 site survey, the 2019 board swap, the 2022 USB insertion, the 2026 object recognition and the 2026 stratigraphic profile all disappeared. Modularity at the end effector and the payload bay outlasts any specific object list. The reading of a judging-reliability motive behind the removals is an inference, not a published policy.

Further reading

Sources for this page

  1. S-URC08-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2008 – Requirements and Guidelines (4 pp PDF)The Mars Society / URC (author K. Sloan), 2007-09-25.Print copy
  2. S-URC13-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2013 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2012 (2013 cycle).Original
  3. S-URC24-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2024 – Requirements and Guidelines (Drive file University Rover Challenge Rules 2024.pdf)The Mars Society / URC, 2023-11 (2024 cycle).Original
  4. S-URC27-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2027 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC.Original Archived copy
  5. S-URC26-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2026 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2025.Original Archived copy
  6. S-URC11-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2011 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2010 (2011 cycle).Original
  7. S-URC19-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2019 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2018 (2019 cycle).Original
  8. S-URC07-RULES-L2University Rover Challenge 2007, Level 2 Requirements and Guidelines (prevails over Level 1)The Mars Society / URC (author J. Lagarde).Print copy
  9. S-URC16-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2016 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2015 (2016 cycle).Original
  10. S-URC17-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2017 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2016 (2017 cycle).Original
  11. S-URC22-RULESUniversity Rover Challenge 2022 – Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC, 2021 (2022 cycle).Original
  12. S-URC07-RULES-L1University Rover Challenge 2007, Level 1 Requirements and GuidelinesThe Mars Society / URC.Print copy